No IR35 precedent set for contractors by island consultants case, experts say

Contractor Insurance

Experts agree that the IR35 case lost by the Stour, West Midlands-based Island Consultants Ltd. did not set a precedent that would affect contractors in the future. (see recent article - Island Consultants Ltd lose IR35 Case.)

Island Consultants Ltd. was engaged by the agency Spring Ltd, to provide business and data analysis on Severn and Trent Water’s five-year project of upgrading their billing system. The project was managed by a Mr Carson and involved STW employees, people from an external software company and contractors. Mr Hough had no managerial responsibility for any of these other workers and had an identity badge that clearly indicated he was a contractor.

Does Not Change Life for Contractors

As John Kell, policy director at the London-based Professional Contractors Group points out, the issue was unfortunate, but not one that changes the basis of the received case law for IR35.

But the implications for contractors are significant, according to the Brighton-based legal consultancy Lawspeed which specialises in contractor affairs.

Significant Implications

Says Lawspeed managing director Adrian Marlowe ''We have always said that the way to operate outside IR35 is to be engaged on a project, which must be real, and the project must be identified as the contractor's project. This will inevitably be part of the client’s project.

''I can see no evidence in this case that the range and scope of the contractor’s project was anything other than for three months supply (at a time) of specialist skills towards STW’s project. Each contract was time based, namely 3 months. I would say that from the way the case is described there is no evidence from this that there was a project for the contractor.''

We have always said that the way to operate outside IR35 is to be engaged on a project which must be real and the project must be identified as the contractor project

Adrian Marlowe-Lawspeed

No Link To A Project

Marlowe points out that merely linking phases to regular periods of time does not assist. The only reference to a project is that of STW. In addition there seems to be no indication of what happened at the end of the project or any argument about what would happen if the project ended at any stage. Indeed the description of the ingredients of the contract appears to be silent on this point other than to refer to a 4 week termination notice. Again we have long argued that notice periods are evidence of potential employment.

''Once you allow yourself to operate without a defined project you open yourself up to the arguments about mutuality, use of equipment, substitution (which rarely lives in the real world) and so on, as has happened in this case,'' Marlowe continues.

''I would also say that the fact that the STW Spring contract did not contemplate proper project terms has added to the problem for Island Consultants. Alll Lawspeed IR35 contracts (as opposed to our standard contracts) that our client agencies use are set up as proper projects and deal with many of the issues raised in this case. Those agencies using our contracts usually operate on our IR35 friendly client terms also.''

Contracts Must Represent Facts

"Where both are used I think it far less likely that the problems encountered here would have occurred (on the assumption of course that there was in fact a project – the contracts cannot put someone outside IR35 if they do not represent the true circumstances),'' Marlowe explains.

Here there may have been a definable contractor project, but it was not properly set out and the ramifications were not properly considered. In addition the client terms did not protect Island Consultants, although this possibly could have been overcome had the issue been addressed early on.

Don't Count on Substitution

''In terms of the representation, it appears from the judgment that there was much emphasis by Island Consultants on the argument about substitution. Again I would say that the substitution point should never in itself be relied upon, and this is a position that we have taken since 2000 in contrast to some other service providers.''

Marlowe points out that reliance on right of substitution was too considerable in this case. ''It seems that the argument about substitution in this case coupled with the technical argument about the identity of the “client” for IR35 purposes and the failure to rely on solid arguments about a project has resulted in Island Consultants losing the case. That is our reading of it from the way that the judgment is expressed.''

An unfortunate but not a precedent setting case

John Kell-PCG

Clearly not a case that will change the way contractors operate, but one that shows the importance of solid professional advice on IR35 matters.

Alliance Accountants

Published: Tuesday, July 24, 2007

© 2014 All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. Please see our copyright notice. If you want to use any content you have seen on this site then please request our media pack and ask for details of our Content Licencing Service.


Inni Accounts

Readers Comments...

Bookmark and Share

Latest Site Updates

ContractorCalculator: Contracting news in brief – 17/Apr/2014 ContractorCalculator: Contracting news in brief – 17/Apr/2014

News this week covers: financial sector recovers; PCG calls for greater contractor support; new powers for HMRC; & late-payment code in construction.

Contractor guide to using substitution to stay outside IR35 Contractor guide to using substitution to stay outside IR35

Contractors who are able to make unfettered substitutions that do not require agreement from the client can use substitution to stay outside IR35.

Contractors and trade unions – can they be compatible? Contractors and trade unions – can they be compatible?

Contractors are independent professionals and also self-employed. Trade unions claim to be all about representing workers? Is there a meeting point?

Financial, HR and IT contractors benefit from London financial sector job surge Financial, HR and IT contractors benefit from London financial sector job surge

IT, HR, compliance and risk specialist contractors are benefitting from a surge in job vacancies, against a background of improving City health.



  • Finance is number in the league table of sectors where IT is growing fast via @siaeurope

    Thu, 17 Apr 2014

  • ContractorCalculator is now on Facebook, so if you wish to receive the latest contracting news connect with us today

    Thu, 17 Apr 2014

  • Institute of Interim Management 2014 IIM survey is open contractors to complete and will run until 10 May 2014

    Thu, 17 Apr 2014

  • ContractorCalculator: Contracting news in brief – 17/Apr/2014

    Thu, 17 Apr 2014

  • Self-employment increases by 146k over the last quarter, shows latest labour market stats from ONS

    Wed, 16 Apr 2014

  • Contractor guide to using substitution to stay outside IR35

    Wed, 16 Apr 2014

Follow Us On Twitter



Contractor solutions

Contractors Handbook Orange and Gold Accountancy Limited IR35 Test Clever Accounts Accountants Checklist Contractors Handbook

Contractor solutions

Alliance Accountants

Complete Accountancy and Taxation service from £55 per month


We can help you make the most of your money

Contractor Angels

More than just an Umbrella. Retain up to 90% of your earnings.

Contractor Accountant

Free consultation, incorporation and IR35 reviews. Find out more…

InTouch Accounting

Perfect mix of technology & personal service for only £92 per month.

Clever Accounts

Complete contractor accounting service. 24/7 online access. £69 pm!

NA D J Colom Accountants Bedouin Group Contractor Financials NewsNow
Caprica Accountants Contractor Insurance Life Insurance


The UK's leading contractor site. Independently audited traffic (ABC) – 123,165 monthly unique visitors.