Contractor’s bid for employment rights denied as Tilson loses Tilson v Alstom appeal

IR35 Test

Contractor Andrew Tilson has lost his bid to overturn a previous ruling by the Employment Appeals Tribunal (EAT) that he was an employee of his former client, Alstom Transport. The Court of Appeal has ruled that there was no direct contractual relationship between Tilson and Alstom Transport, upholding the decision of the EAT.

Tilson’s original case gained notoriety in June 2009, when an Employment Tribunal ruled that his relationship with Alstom Transport was one of employment, and that the contractor qualified for employment rights. This in turn meant he could claim unfair dismissal from Alstom Transport when his contract was terminated. It was the first ruling of its kind since the James v Greenwich ruling set a precedent denying all contractors employment rights.

However, in the decision in the Court of Appeal on 19 November 2010, Lord Justice Elias confirmed that the Employment Appeals Tribunal was right to reject the original Employment Tribunal ruling as being ‘misdirected in law’.

“…there was no proper basis on which any employment tribunal, properly directing itself on these facts, could find that there was a direct contractual relationship between Alstom and the appellant,” Elias confirmed in the ruling. The decision was unanimous, with fellow judges Lord Justice Pitchford and Lady Justice Arden in complete agreement.

The judge cited a number of factors contributing to the decision. These included the lack of intention to form an employment contract between Tilson and Alstom Transport. Another important factor was that integration of a worker into an organisation and having to apply to a line manager before taking leave does not automatically imply the existence of an employment contract.

The decision of the court of appeal is likely to end the hopes of long-term ‘permtractors’ that they may qualify for employment rights from end-user clients. It also means that genuine contractors facing IR35 investigations will not be able to use the original ruling to support their defences.


Alliance Accountants

Published: Thursday, November 25, 2010

© 2014 All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. Please see our copyright notice. If you want to use any content you have seen on this site then please request our media pack and ask for details of our Content Licencing Service.

  
  

Inni Accounts


Readers Comments...


  
Bookmark and Share
  
     
  

Latest Site Updates

Contractors: You’re all guilty now Contractors: You’re all guilty now

Contractors and other taxpayers are being bullied into tax settlements with HMRC without having the opportunity to benefit from due process & the law.

Contractors learn the big secret of the BBC “employment test”: it’s useless Contractors learn the big secret of the BBC “employment test”: it’s useless

ContractorCalculator’s long campaign to get the BBC to reveal its employment test has shown the test to be new layer of pointless, costly bureaucracy.

Why hand the taxman more powers when HMRC fails to enforce the rules it has? Why hand the taxman more powers when HMRC fails to enforce the rules it has?

HMRC is being handed yet more powers, but it fails even to enforce those it has now. Does it really need new ones?

Contracting market in Scotland hits 11.5 year peak: rates up, contract numbers high Contracting market in Scotland hits 11.5 year peak: rates up, contract numbers high

Scotland’s market is in rude health, showing surging demand for contractors alongside increasing rates. This mirrors positive signs in the wider UK.


  
  

Twitter

Follow Us On Twitter


  
     

  
  

Contractor solutions

Contractor Angels Orange and Gold Accountancy Limited IR35 Test Clever Accounts Accountants Checklist Alliance Accountants
  
  

Contractor solutions

Contractor Angels

More than just an Umbrella. Retain up to 90% of your earnings.

Clever Accounts

Complete contractor accounting service. 24/7 online access. £69 pm!

Contractor Accountant

Free consultation, incorporation and IR35 reviews. Find out more…

Need an accountant?

Comprehensive service for £55 per month. Call now for a FREE consultation.

Parasol

The UK’s largest employment organisation - 0% risk, 100% compliance

InTouch Accounting

Perfect mix of technology & personal service for only £92 per month.

NA Bedouin Group D J Colom Accountants Contractor Financials NewsNow
  
Caprica Accountants Contractor Angels Contractor Insurance Life Insurance

  

The UK's leading contractor site. Independently audited traffic (ABC) – 131,456 monthly unique visitors.