Contractor ‘employment’ status clarified as Tilson ruling is overturned on appeal

Contractor Insurance

Contractors concerned about having their employment status called into question as a result of last year’s Tilson versus Alstom Transport ruling can be reassured, as an Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) judge has overturned the original ruling on appeal. Contractor Andrew Tilson was awarded employment rights, in the form of a claim for unfair dismissal, by Employment Judge Smail at an Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) in March 2009.

Tilson’s end-user client Alstom Transport appealed the decision and EAT Judge McMullen upheld the appeal, denying Tilson employment rights. This was done on the basis that Judge Smail was wrong to have dismissed the contracts as being a ‘sham’. Further weight behind the decision came from the fact that Alstom Transport’s counsel was not given the opportunity to present additional evidence to confirm the contracts were indeed valid.

Matt Boddington from Accountax was not surprised to see the appeal succeed: “This was not an unexpected outcome in the circumstances and demonstrates that when parties strike a bargain with their eyes open on the basis of a client and independent contractor relationship, then the Courts will uphold that view. This is a sensible and pragmatic result.”

However, Boddington’s view is that the ruling will have little significance for IR35 cases, as he explains: “The [IR35] legislation allows HMRC to construe an implied legal relationship where one does not actually exist, whereas employment law generally does not, which is the main thrust of this ruling.”

Intention of the parties is relevant

Commenting that the case was visiting “yet again the complex relationships of agency workers”, Judge McMullen noted that Judge Smail had “referred to the leading authorities but there have been further developments in this area since his judgement.”

This was not an unexpected outcome in the circumstances and demonstrates that when parties strike a bargain with their eyes open on the basis of a client and independent contractor relationship, then the Courts will uphold that view

Matt Boddington, Accountax

McMullen went on to highlight that it was clearly the intention of Tilson to be a contractor, and that he had actively resisted attempts by Alstom Transport to recruit him to become an employee.

“The intention of the Claimant [Tilson] was to remain an independent contractor, and the intention of the Respondent [Alstom Transport] was to change that so as to bring him onto the staff,” said McMullen, “Thus, if the intention of the parties was looked at, the relationship was only one of independent contractor.”

Original tribunal judge ‘wrong in law’

Tilson won the original ruling on the basis that Judge Smail concluded that the contracts between his payroll company Silversun Solutions, the agency Morson Human Resources, and the end-user client Alstom Transport were a sham, and that the notional contract was one of employment.

According to Judge McMullen: “Deciding whether a document accurately reflects the reality, or is on the other hand a complete sham, involves a holistic approach to the document, and the judge [Smail] did not take that.”

Implications for contractors

Immediately following the announcement of the original ruling in July 2009, employment law experts privately expressed to ContractorCalculator their view that the ruling by Judge Smail was in error and that any appeal mounted by Alstom Transport would most likely be successful.

Any hope that ‘perm-tractors’ might secure employment rights for themselves have been dashed, although as highlighted by Accountax’s Boddington, genuine contractors in business on their own right will not be able to use the ruling to support an IR35 defence.

But what is now certain is that contractors will not find the original ruling used as case law to determine that their legitimate contractual relationship with the agency and end-user client is called into question as a sham.


Alliance Accountants

Published: Wednesday, February 03, 2010

© 2014 All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. Please see our copyright notice. If you want to use any content you have seen on this site then please request our media pack and ask for details of our Content Licencing Service.

  
  

Inni Accounts


Readers Comments...


  
Bookmark and Share
  
     
  

Latest Site Updates

ContractorCalculator: Contracting news in brief – 17/Apr/2014 ContractorCalculator: Contracting news in brief – 17/Apr/2014

News this week covers: financial sector recovers; PCG calls for greater contractor support; new powers for HMRC; & late-payment code in construction.

Contractor guide to using substitution to stay outside IR35 Contractor guide to using substitution to stay outside IR35

Contractors who are able to make unfettered substitutions that do not require agreement from the client can use substitution to stay outside IR35.

Contractors and trade unions – can they be compatible? Contractors and trade unions – can they be compatible?

Contractors are independent professionals and also self-employed. Trade unions claim to be all about representing workers? Is there a meeting point?

Financial, HR and IT contractors benefit from London financial sector job surge Financial, HR and IT contractors benefit from London financial sector job surge

IT, HR, compliance and risk specialist contractors are benefitting from a surge in job vacancies, against a background of improving City health.


  
  

Twitter

  • Finance is number in the league table of sectors where IT is growing fast http://t.co/G6sTiNftwB via @siaeurope

    Thu, 17 Apr 2014

  • ContractorCalculator is now on Facebook, so if you wish to receive the latest contracting news connect with us today https://t.co/pPMQmQSmAL

    Thu, 17 Apr 2014

  • Institute of Interim Management 2014 IIM survey is open contractors to complete and will run until 10 May 2014 http://t.co/BQtVrRipAQ

    Thu, 17 Apr 2014

  • ContractorCalculator: Contracting news in brief – 17/Apr/2014 http://t.co/JhNa9rsArf

    Thu, 17 Apr 2014

  • Self-employment increases by 146k over the last quarter, shows latest labour market stats from ONS http://t.co/6Hjh6app73

    Wed, 16 Apr 2014

  • Contractor guide to using substitution to stay outside IR35 http://t.co/Cf0lbR4Il9

    Wed, 16 Apr 2014

Follow Us On Twitter


  
     

  
  

Contractor solutions

Contractors Handbook Orange and Gold Accountancy Limited IR35 Test Clever Accounts Accountants Checklist Contractors Handbook
  
  

Contractor solutions

Alliance Accountants

Complete Accountancy and Taxation service from £55 per month

Parasol

We can help you make the most of your money

Contractor Angels

More than just an Umbrella. Retain up to 90% of your earnings.

Contractor Accountant

Free consultation, incorporation and IR35 reviews. Find out more…

InTouch Accounting

Perfect mix of technology & personal service for only £92 per month.

Clever Accounts

Complete contractor accounting service. 24/7 online access. £69 pm!

NA D J Colom Accountants Bedouin Group Contractor Financials NewsNow
  
Caprica Accountants Contractor Insurance Life Insurance

  

The UK's leading contractor site. Independently audited traffic (ABC) – 123,165 monthly unique visitors.