Contractor doctor: can I sue for a a last-minute contract cancellation?

InTouch Accounting

Dear Contractor Doctor,

I recently won a contract with a major IT company and received a 'confirmation of employment' email from them confirming the day rate and start date. This was direct with a client with whom I interviewed; there was no agency involved.

Having noticed that the start date in the email did not match what I had agreed a matter of minutes earlier (it was a matter of a couple of days difference), I wrote back informing them of the error. I received another email stating that they had agreed to the start date I had originally offered.

Then came the surprise. On the evening before my start date, I found a phone message on my voice mail cancelling the contract.

This was a terrible blow, because I had left a good position in order to take this offer. Can I sue?

Thanks,

Andrew

Contractor Doctor says:

We at ContractorCalculator are shocked by this story--and we thought we'd heard it all. It's bad enough to confirm a contract with a simple email--and you should always in the future obtain a written contract for any assignment--but then to cancel with a mere phone message is truly callous behaviour. No contractor should be treated in this cavalier fashion.

Yes, you should sue. The emails you received are fully sufficient proof of the existence of a contract. And the fact that you interviewed with the company shows that they gave thought to the matter before sending you the emails--meaning that it wasn't some sort of mistake on their part.

Normally a contract should have a termination clause, but yours doesn't, and so standard practice in the industry kicks in which is normally at least 4 weeks. But there is more at stake here, because you left a good job for the position and they've terminated you without even giving you a chance to earn anything. The value of what you've lost is greater than the termination period, and your lawyer should go into calculating damages with you in detail.

Do remember that you have what is called a 'Duty to Mitigate.' This means that you can't just quit work for the entire term of the contract and expect to be paid: the judges will expect you to make a real attempt at finding more work in the meantime.

Good luck with your contracting!

Contractor Doctor

Published: Wednesday, November 28, 2007

© 2012 All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. Please see our copyright notice. If you want to use any content you have seen on this site then please request our media pack and ask for details of our Content Licencing Service.


Readers Comments...

This article has 1 comment.

Comment on this articleComment on this article

Speech Bubble Added: Mon, 03 Dec 2007

Andrew, Welcome to the real world mate. I do feel sorry for what happened. But, IMHO, the contractor doctors advice takes legal stuff into account, but has missed the commercial practicality. The client is already happy with you and another potential opportunity with them is not far away. You sue them and you loose any business with them in the future. Talk with the person who interviewed you to see what the situation is and why the contract was cancelled.

The world of contracting has uncertainity written all over it. If you want certainity, then contracting is not right for you. Take this as an experience and move on. Keep in touch with the client and you'll have work come your way soon. Good luck.

SS, NL.

Recommended by 0 readers.

Sign in to recommend comments

Comment on this articleComment on this article


  
Bookmark and Share
  
     
  

Latest Site Updates

Does HMRC even know where its ‘better administration of IR35’ target is? Does HMRC even know where its ‘better administration of IR35’ target is?

If contractors agree to trial HMRC’s new IR35 framework for 12 months, how are we going to measure if ‘better administration’ has been achieved?

ContractorCalculator: Contracting news in brief - 18/May/2012 ContractorCalculator: Contracting news in brief - 18/May/2012

News this week includes the latest IR35 insights; P35 advice; contractor demand data; partial financial sector recovery; & HMRC service improvements.

P35 guidance: unsure contractors should answer ‘no’ to service co question, says HMRC P35 guidance: unsure contractors should answer ‘no’ to service co question, says HMRC

Contractors are not legally obliged to answer the P35 question 6, ‘Are you a Service Company?’, and if they’re unsure should answer ‘no’.

No certainty from HMRC’s new IR35 framework, but the policy debate must be sustained No certainty from HMRC’s new IR35 framework, but the policy debate must be sustained

No certainty for limited company contractors yet, but the policy debate is far from over, say OTS Tax Director John Whiting and PCG’s Simon McVicker.


  
  

Twitter

  • Does HMRC even know where its ‘better administration of IR35’ target is? http://t.co/L3MuqlFz

    7 hours ago

  • IT leads surge in Scottish contract recruitment : Bank of Scotland Report on Jobs http://t.co/QIrLKFGb

    7 hours ago

  • How might government's 'secret plan' to link civil service earnings to location affect public sector contractor rates? http://t.co/fJClb0HG

    Sun, 20 May 2012

  • IT contractors have a key enabling role to play in the UK retail sector's 'third revolution' http://t.co/zjx00EfY via @MT_editorial

    Fri, 18 May 2012

  • ContractorCalculator: Contracting news in brief - 18/May/2012 http://t.co/SDkQNjdZ

    Fri, 18 May 2012

  • Uncertainty over Scottish independence 'harmful to Scotland plc' impacting on oil & gas decisions http://t.co/ZKo2jCsQ via @scotsmannews

    Fri, 18 May 2012

Follow Us On Twitter


  
     

  
  

Contractor solutions

Contractors Handbook AM Limited IR35 Test
  
Contractor accountants - pricing checklist
  

Contractor solutions

Parasol Group

Umbrella or Limited? Guidance on best options, and take home pay.

Choice Premier Pay+

Take home up to 85% of your pay. IR35 solution.

Contractors Handbook

The expert guide for UK contractors and freelancers

InTouch Accounting

Person to person contractor accountant. Free IR35 review.

Bedouin Group

No more IR35. Retain up to 85% of your earnings.

NA D J Colom Accountants Bedouin Group Contractor Financials NewsNow
  
Elevate

  

The UK's leading contractor site. Independently audited traffic (ABC) – 156,346 monthly unique visitors.